Hey, it's your fav email guy.

Should you focus on paid ads or email? Media buyers swear by ads, email people swear by email. My answer annoys both camps.

The case for ads

Ads are the top of your funnel, the only reliable way to point traffic at your site on demand. Organic and SEO are cheaper but unpredictable. With ads you can scale traffic up instantly and predictably.

The catch is cost. You pay for creative and placement, prices keep climbing, and you play by Meta's rules: approvals, content limits, the occasional ban, and a platform that breaks at the worst times.

The case for email

Email is the bottom of your funnel, how you nurture non-buyers until they trust you enough to buy. It's a predictable sequence you fully control, you own the list, the timing, the copy, the look, with no risk of getting banned. You also get retention: once you have someone's email, you can keep marketing to them for almost nothing.

You'll hear email quoted at 4000% ROI vs ~200% for ads. Take the exact number with a grain of salt (it's from broad surveys and swings wildly), but the direction holds: cost per touch is in a different league.

Quick side by side:

• Job in the funnel: ads acquire attention, email converts and keeps it.

• Cost: ads are expensive, email is cheap.

• Who controls it: Meta and Google control your ads, you control your email.

The catch with both

So email wins? Not quite, it relies on attention it doesn't have yet. You can't email people who never signed up, and you can't get signups without something bringing them to your site first. That something is usually ads.

So ads win? Also no. People need to see a brand around seven times before they buy. Without email in the back end, you're buying all seven impressions with ads, which is brutal. You break even on the first order, then pay again to get them back.

Put an email popup and proper flows in place and the math flips: pay for one or two ad impressions to get someone on the list, then deliver the rest of those trust-building touches by email for almost nothing.

The verdict

No brand grows profitably on just one. They're two halves of the same machine: ads buy the attention, email converts and retains it. The order is what matters. Dial in your email systems first, then scale up your ad spend, so you only pay the premium for attention once and convert it cheaply from there.

Have a good one,

MailedBy